There is one word or phrase that is repeated endlessly during the bariatric surgery preparation. Contrary to popular belief, it’s not “weight loss” or “losing weight” or any variation of those two words. It’s “protein, protein, protein” or “Make sure you get in your protein.”
Why? Protein, for one, helps us stay fuller longer. That is essential when, starting out, your meals could fit into an egg. I’m not joking. Your meals are about 4 ounces. That small size makes protein key for helping you feel full and not want to eat between meals. Second, protein helps repair our muscles and injuries. After surgery, you’ve just had a major injury happen to the inside of your body and you need to heal.
There are so many protein drinks on the market, which ones should you use? In this week’s post, I’m giving you my honest feedback on a variety of drinks. Now remember, everyone has his/her favorite and that depends on a variety of things like their taste buds, consistency of the drinks, convenience or ease of getting them, costs, etc. Just know, this is my own personal opinion.
Ready to Drink- “Shakes”
After surgery, the nutritionist and staff said the “shake” consistency drinks might be too much on a healing stomach. I didn’t have that problem. In fact, I preferred these to the fruit-drink ones I’ll touch base on later.
Prior to the surgery, I was never a “ready to drink” protein person. I always made mine with a powder and blender. After the surgery, it was just easier to run into the fridge and grab a shake and drink it without fooling with blending ice, adding milk or water, etc. To this day, I’m still a huge fan of the “Ready-to-drink” shakes.
My favorite brand of these is the Premier Protein drinks for many, many reason. First, they are readily available at Wal-Mart or Walgreen’s. I never had an instance where either store is completely out of the drink. Second, there are so many different flavors and it seems like they come out with more all the time. So far, I’ve tried the standard vanilla, chocolate and strawberry. I’ve also had their newer flavors like Cookies ‘N Creme, Banana Cream and Peaches ‘N Cream. There’s also a salted caramel one, which was the only flavor I didn’t like. It was just too sweet for me. At the price point, you can play around with the flavors and not feel bad if you dislike one kind so much that you can’t drink it. That brings me to my third point, the cost. Each package contains four drinks for around $7.47 per pack. It’s actually a pretty reasonable price in regards to protein drinks. Fourth, the expiration date is usually a pretty long way into the future. Meaning, you don’t have to worry about them expiring like a true “milk-based” shake. Finally, check out the grams of protein per bottle- 30 grams of protein! That’s almost halfway to your daily protein goal.
The cons to Premier Protein? So far, there’s only one that I’ve come across. You really have to make sure you shake up the drink vigorously to mix it. There were a few times with the peach one that I didn’t and ended up with a lumpy protein drink, which made me shy away from using them for quite some time.
Taste-wise, my personal favorite is the Rock’N Lean Protein, which I can find in my dairy case at the supermarket.
This protein drink tastes like an actual chocolate milk shake. Budget-wise, you are paying for a single bottle of it, which isn’t always cost-effective. So far, I’ve only noticed the chocolate flavor and it does have an expiration date that you need to watch. I’ve had to throw away a few bottles because it expired. There’s also another version that has low sugar, but the consistency was like drinking pudding. Make sure, you try the Lean version.
Muscle Milk is another great ready-to-drink option. Just make sure you grab the “light” version and not the full fledge one. There are more calories and grams of sugar in the regular recipe. You don’t want dumping syndrome to occur!
Again, it’s easier to find in Wal-Mart and Walgreens, which are our two standard stores in my small town. The cost is actually cheaper than Premier at $5.77 per package. Here’s the catch- each serving has 10 grams less of protein than Premier, which would explain why it’s slightly cheaper. In spite of that, it’s still a great option. Again, the product doesn’t expire right away and the taste is pretty decent. It might be a little chalkier than Premier, but not much.
The Atkins shakes have even less protein than the previous two at 15 grams were bottle and costs around $5.89 per four-pack. I’ve seen plenty at our local stores, so I don’t think they will “run out”, but I have to say that I tried these one time and that was more than enough! In my opinion, the taste was everything I thought a protein shake might be: chalky and with an aftertaste that reminded me of the nasty cough syrup my mother made me take when I was 10.
On the flip side, I have a friend who routinely drinks protein drinks and he doesn’t think these are half-bad. I disagreed. We are still friends, but I know I won’t share his protein drinks anytime soon! LOL.
Those are the main “ready to drink” ones that I tried and can give an honest review about. There are others, quite a few others, on the market. Just read the labels! Several, including the one the hospital gave me to drink the day after surgery, have way more sugar per serving than these and should be avoided. In addition, I like to remain on the side of caution- if you are drinking a protein drink whether it’s for convenience or protein, shouldn’t you choose the one(s) that give you the most protein per serving?
Ready to Drink- Fruit-Based
I think my problem with this group is that I expect these to taste like fruit juice and that’s not the case. Besides tasting a little “off,” in my opinion, they almost left a weird coating or film in my mouth and throat. The only way to describe it is by comparing it to drinking semi-warm Jello-O. It’s slightly thicker than water and leaves a film.
I ordered these from GNC. They comes in a heavy glass bottle and reminded me of a typical bottled-soda size that you would buy at a convenience store. There were many flavors available, but our area GNC had a limited number, which I completely understood and I also ordered some online. In my opinion, the cost wasn’t outrageous for what you are getting, but some people might want to shy away from it.
This bottle- this single bottle has 40 grams of protein in it! In theory, you could sip it all day. Here are the negatives in my opinion: I only liked the green apple flavor and I could barely tolerate it; it tasted almost like medicine disguised as something else. Not knowing any better, I ordered two cases of the red and blue online, during a cold spell and they froze in transit. Which I didn’t know about when I placed them inside my house, causing them to melt with the bottles bursting all over the place. Like the liquid did when I drank it, they too, left a film all over my floor.
On the bright side, GNC replaced all of the broken bottles at no charge. The negative was I had to find someone to give them to as I couldn’t bring myself to drink any of it.
The nectar brand is available at most bariatric sites like bariatricpal.com. I liked this better than the Isopure and you could order small servings of a bunch of different flavors, including a chocolate one which gave me plenty of variety. I didn’t mind the taste of these. They still had this “filmy” aftertaste, but it was tolerable and nice to have something different. I think I liked them the best when they were ice cold. My favorites were the peach and chocolate.
A lot of bariatric patients will make these and them freeze them like a popsicle. They get a frozen “treat” while getting in their protein.
So, one day, I craved fruit juice and not just mixing some with half water. I wanted something comforting that tasted like real juice, so I ordered this variety pack.
First of all, don’t order something because you are craving something else. It will never compare to the real thing. Second, these fruit-flavored beverages aren’t meant to be “juice”, so of course, it didn’t taste like that. While the price was reasonable and I could find them easily online, I didn’t like the taste or the film that came afterwards.
Again, these are all viable options for your protein. Don’t avoid them because I didn’t like the taste- I have friends who love all of these. I think when it comes to ready-to-drink protein supplements, you have to experiment and see which ones are for you.
Protein Powders
My most favorite protein powder is the 100% whey protein from GNC in chocolate. I got a lot of protein in one serving and it tasted as close to a chocolate milkshake as I could get at home without ice cream. Cost-wise, it was a little bit higher than ones I could find elsewhere, but I felt it was worth it when you factored in something like the taste. When I’m talking “higher,” it was less than $7.
If you are looking for taste and variety, then I’d try Quest Protein. I think this company has invented a flavor for virtually any craving: chocolate, cookies and cream, cinnamon crunch, etc. For the most part, all of the flavors I’ve tried have been pretty spot-on.
Now, here’s the hitch. The containers are a pretty good-size and run about $29.99 per container. So, if you are on a budget, having one flavor day after day after day can get pretty old. If you order a chocolate mousse flavor, for example, you better like chocolate. If budget isn’t a concern, then I’d order two or three containers of different flavors so you don’t feel like “Here I go again, ANOTHER chocolate protein drink.”
For a savory element, you can add unflavored protein powder to things like soup or broth and still get your protein. The downfall? First, you really have to stir or shake to get all the protein blended in or else you might get protein ball lumps. Second, it adds almost a milk-like texture to the broth. So, a beef broth might end up tasting like a cream-based beefy broth like a clam chowder. It was helpful and I used this trick to get me through the seven-day liquid diet prior to surgery, but it wasn’t something I actively sought out and wanted daily. If you go this route, GNC has a great one, which I’ve posted that doesn’t break the bank.
I hope this helps you in your search for the perfect protein. I think several things need to be factors in your decision. First, taste is right up there. If it tastes bad, you won’t want to drink it, which will make it harder to meet your goals. Second, being a bariatric patient isn’t cheap. There’s vitamins, supplements like protein, and purchasing a lot of smaller clothes. A lot of smaller clothes. When you think you’re good for a while, you drop down another size, which leads to more clothes. Just use your time, pre-op to experiment. Swap out an afternoon snack with a different protein shake and learn, ahead of time, which ones are your favorite and why. Then after surgery, you won’t need to stress!
Good luck in your perfect protein search. I hope this helps and I wish you great success on your weight loss journey!